I Am the Fated Villain

You must log in to post a comment.

1. 

   Ink Librarian • 18/03/2026 at 11:11 pm

   Look, I don't know how this Manhwa has such a high rating. To be honest, it makes me wonder if whoever is rating it, hasn't read this THING. Is the idea and the basis of this Manhwa good? Yes! Is the art style good? Yes! But it commits 3 sins that the author apparently doesn't realize even after more than 300 chapters:1- He refuses to understand that making the new protagonist, the reincarnated guy, into  such a shallow and unempathetic, is a mistake, especially if you're going to keep him with those characteristics, even after advancing the story and the Manhwa.2- The point of a reincarnated person changing the story is to give new character developments, the insemination of the reincarnated person becoming part of the world or the character they entered, and showing new and different alternative plot outcomes. Something he only partially does here, and it's driven by a cold and unsympathetic intention on the part of the reincarnated guy.3- When the moment arrives when the Reincarnated should feel touched by what he has done, or when the author shows that the original protagonist may not be a good or righteous person, it is always overshadowed by the fact that the reincarnated still sees the world he is in as a random, unimportant story, almost with disdain, or like a player who doesn't care about the game but wants to platinum it, which prevents you from feeling attraction or agreement with him.I read and saw these 3 sins happening repeatedly, clearly showing the author's flaws and intentions right from the first 10 chapters. In the following chapters, which I read, 11-23, it was the same thing: face-slapping reversal, and the reincarnated still seeing the world as a game to complete without becoming familiar with it or forming bonds, and even the cultivation system isn't good; it's copied from other places.

   Log in to Reply
2. 

   Ink Librarian • 18/05/2026 at 9:43 pm

   After 3 months I finally had the courage to come back to this manhwa and try reading more of it in the hope that it would improve... Unfortunately, that's not the case. It still has good art, a good idea and story base, and an interesting premise. However, its main problem is the protagonist; it's just not worth it, unless you're tired of clichés and hate them so much that you want to see the protagonist massacre them and the "heralds" who represent them, then maybe you can read until the end of the first season. But the problem remains: ONE protagonist, shallow, unsympathetic, devoid of empathy, who sees the world as a game in the simplest and driest way possible, even being disdainful at times. I still stick with my analogy that he seems like an ignorant gamer who wants to "PLATINUM" the game without caring about it; he just wants to show off on his account that he got the platinum trophy. Rating: 3

   Log in to Reply